Build a fallout shelter against Nuclear Verdicts®

January 17, 2024

Have you heard of “Nuclear Verdicts®”? No, it’s not a new military stratagem involving ballistic missiles, but they are about as devastating as one.

Nuclear verdicts are rulings against companies with payouts in the millions. Over the past 10 years, two-thirds of these verdicts occurred in product liability, auto accident and medical liability cases.

There’s more to this, however. Nuclear verdicts don’t just happen in a vacuum. The plaintiff’s attorneys usually frame the company’s actions as deeply negligent, dangerous and preventable.

Juries are persuaded of the perceived risk that these companies pose, and rule that the payouts should be punitive and expensive. These multi-million-dollar damages have the capacity to hollow out and bankrupt companies, eating through its insurance like tissue paper.

The issue isn’t necessarily that these companies are found guilty. After all, the evidence and arguments prove that these companies were responsible for wrongdoing.

The issue lies in these payouts, which can destroy smaller companies that may be vital to the local economy. These payouts also dig deep into the pockets of insurance companies: insurance provides an important safety net for services in society, and eroding at it with nuclear verdicts can do long-term damage.

Ultimately, how should companies protect themselves from these verdicts? For starters, prevention is one of the best steps companies can take. All companies should meet compliance standards, but going the extra mile for safety can help.

Providing extensive training, regularly updating employee manuals and maintaining equipment are just a few things companies can do to keep workers and the public safe. It makes it less likely a company will have to pay heavy damages if it can prove that safety was its top priority. This also keeps insurance companies from digging less deeply into their pockets to cover damages.

There also are systemic solutions, like introducing legislation to put caps on payouts or providing evidence in the proper context in court, but this route would take grassroots effort, time and money.

In the last 10 years, the median cost of nuclear verdicts is $20 million dollars according to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce on page eight of their report on nuclear verdicts, but the mean cost of these verdicts is at $76 million dollars. This means that there are enough verdicts that are so expensive that they skew the data set and drag up the mean.

If professional insurance agents frequently provide coverage for business owners, they should have a discussion with them to help provide the necessary safeguards to protect themselves from these costly and devesting verdicts. While businesses can be found liable for wrongdoing, settlements that hollow out a company can create a ripple that affects employees and the community the business is a part of.

PIA Northeast |  + posts

Matt McDonough is PIA Northeast's writer, editor and content curator. Matt joined PIA Northeast in September 2023. Before that, he had been an editor for the online entertainment magazine Collider from 2021-23 as a copy editor for its lists section. Matt entered the world of journalism at his alma mater, SUNY New Paltz, writing and reporting for the college's student run newspaper, The New Paltz Oracle. He graduated from SUNY New Paltz with a Bachelor of Arts in English and a minor in Creative Writing in 2020.

Your ad could be here. ads@pia.org

Related stories…

Conn.: Legislative session recap: Reform achieved, risks mitigated and the road ahead 

Conn.: Legislative session recap: Reform achieved, risks mitigated and the road ahead 

At the start of the 2025 Connecticut legislative session, PIACT set an ambitious goal to make significant reforms to the state’s excess and surplus lines placement process; protect consumers from increased premiums; and protect producers from errors-and-omissions exposures. Now with the 2025 session in the rearview mirror, PIACT can claim with confidence: Mission accomplished.  With the passage of H.B.6981, PIACT secured a major win that will modernize the way brokers access the E&S market. Meanwhile, PIACT engaged in advocacy on bills related to flood insurance disclosures, dog breed underwriting and fossil fuel infrastructure surcharges—shaping outcomes that reflect the realities and needs of producers and consumers alike.

Sewer backup insurance and you

Sewer backup insurance and you

Water is everywhere—and it could damage your home and property. From torrential downpours to faulty plumbing, your...

PIANJ | PIANY Annual Conference—a chart-topping success for insurance professionals

PIANJ | PIANY Annual Conference—a chart-topping success for insurance professionals

Some 1,700 insurance professionals from across the Northeast—record-breaking attendance since the COVID-19 pandemic—kicked up their boots and took center stage at the PIANJ | PIANY Annual Conference June 8-10, 2025, at the Hard Rock Hotel Casino, Atlantic City, N.J. Speakers, education sessions and a panel on artificial intelligence all provided attendees with educational opportunities—while the sold-out trade show and various social events provided the backdrop to numerous networking opportunities.

Share This